Economic Efficiency Assessment of Sustainability Investment in EU Member States: A Data Envelopment Analysis with Crisis Impact Evaluation (2015-2024)

Abstract

The article proposes an approach for assessing the efficiency of sustainability-related investments in the EU-27 member states over the period 2015–2024. This is achieved through a combination of a DEA-based approach, a composite efficiency coefficient, and cluster analysis. The composite coefficient measures the relationship between calibrated outcomes and inputs and, in essence, provides a “value-for-money” assessment of sustainable expenditures. The results show substantial differences between countries. The Baltic states and several Central and Eastern European economies display high efficiency, while some of the traditional “leaders” in sustainability exhibit more modest returns per unit of investment. The cluster analysis groups the countries into four clusters with similar characteristics. These range from groups in which investment volumes play the leading role to groups in which efficiency is the key driver, and clearly show differences in the outcomes of the policies pursued (including target-setting and the design of EU financial instruments). The analysis also takes into account the impact of COVID-19 and the war in Ukraine. The main finding is that institutional quality is a stronger factor in maintaining efficiency during crises than the level of economic development. This conclusion underlines that sustainability objectives should also include measurable indicators of administrative capacity in order to improve the system’s ability to adapt in times of crisis. The proposed model provides an empirical basis for improving the way European targets and instruments are formulated. It can help direct limited resources more effectively towards countries and regions with the greatest potential for efficiency improvement.